Mere Christianityintermediate
Explain how Lewis responds to the objection that moral rules are merely social conventions.
Answer
A strong answer should distinguish conventions, such as which side of the road people use, from standards that Lewis regards as more widely shared and open to moral evaluation. It should explain that calling one moral code better than another assumes a standard by which both can be assessed. Lewis also distinguishes disagreements about moral principles from disagreements about facts.
Explanation
### Why this is right
Lewis’s response depends on the difference between a convention that could readily have been otherwise and a standard that people use to judge conduct. He also argues that moral progress would be unintelligible if every society’s approval created its own unchallengeable standard.
### The concept
A convention is a shared practice that could vary without changing the underlying moral question, such as driving on the left or right. Lewis argues that moral codes show differences, but also share basic expectations. When people call one code better, they implicitly compare both codes with a standard that is not identical to either society’s opinion. He also warns that some apparent moral changes are changes in factual belief, not moral principle.
### What a good answer covers
- A clear contrast between convention and moral standard.
- The role of moral comparison and the idea of progress.
- The distinction between disagreements about values and disagreements about facts.
### Terms
- **Convention**: A socially agreed practice that could have been established differently.
- **Moral progress**: Improvement measured against a standard, rather than mere change over time.
### Remember
Calling one moral code better than another assumes a standard beyond local preference.
Related Questions
- In Lewis’s piano analogy, what corresponds to the Moral Law?(intermediate)
- Reconstruct Lewis’s inference from the Moral Law to a power behind the universe, and identify one limit he places on that inference.(intermediate)
- In Lewis’s account, what makes free will valuable despite making evil possible?(intermediate)
- Lewis claims that every culture has identical moral rules in every detail.(intermediate)
- Lewis argues that the Moral Law is simply a description of what human beings usually do.(intermediate)
Want to practice more questions like this?
Join myBenkio free and practice past questions for your Nigerian university courses with AI explanations for every answer.
Start Practicing Free