Mere Christianityintermediate
Reconstruct Lewis’s inference from the Moral Law to a power behind the universe, and identify one limit he places on that inference.
Answer
Lewis argues that the Moral Law is real, is not invented by individuals, and is not reducible to observed behaviour or convenience. Because people encounter it as an obligation, he infers that something beyond material facts may be directing the universe. He explicitly says this does not yet establish the personal God of Christian theology.
Explanation
### Why this is right
The inference proceeds from moral experience: people recognize an obligation that cannot be reduced to what they happen to do or prefer. Lewis treats that obligation as evidence of a reality beyond ordinary material facts, while acknowledging that the conclusion is limited.
### The concept
Lewis contrasts materialist explanations of the universe with a religious view in which something mind-like lies behind it. The Moral Law is his distinctive evidence because people have first-person access to the experience of obligation. He does not claim that this argument alone proves every Christian doctrine or even a fully personal God. It is an initial step, not the entire case.
### What a good answer covers
- The Moral Law is more than behaviour, instinct, or convenience.
- Moral obligation is treated as evidence of something beyond material facts.
- Lewis’s conclusion is tentative and does not yet establish Christian theology.
### Remember
Lewis presents the Moral Law as a clue to a power behind the universe, not as a complete proof of Christianity.
Related Questions
- In Lewis’s piano analogy, what corresponds to the Moral Law?(intermediate)
- Explain how Lewis responds to the objection that moral rules are merely social conventions.(intermediate)
- In Lewis’s account, what makes free will valuable despite making evil possible?(intermediate)
- Lewis claims that every culture has identical moral rules in every detail.(intermediate)
- Lewis argues that the Moral Law is simply a description of what human beings usually do.(intermediate)
Want to practice more questions like this?
Join myBenkio free and practice past questions for your Nigerian university courses with AI explanations for every answer.
Start Practicing Free