Cyberlaw, Ethics and Privacyintermediate
Explain why the argument “All birds can fly; penguins are birds; therefore penguins can fly” is valid but unsound.
Answer
The conclusion follows from the premises' structure: if all birds can fly and penguins are birds, penguins must be able to fly. That makes the argument valid. However, the premise that all birds can fly is false because penguins cannot fly. Since a sound argument must be valid and have true premises, this argument is unsound. Its unsoundness does not mean that every unsound argument has a false conclusion; it means at least one condition for soundness fails.
Explanation
### What a good answer covers
- Explain that the conclusion follows if both premises are assumed true, which establishes validity.
- Identify “All birds can fly” as false, so the argument is not sound.
- Distinguish a false premise from an invalid logical structure.
- Clarify that unsoundness does not automatically make a conclusion false.
### The concept
A deductive argument is **valid** when its form guarantees the conclusion under the assumption that its premises are true. It is **sound** only when it is valid and all premises are actually true. The bird example preserves the logical pattern: if every member of a category can fly and penguins belong to that category, then penguins can fly. The problem is that the broad premise is factually false. This example shows why you should assess structure separately from factual accuracy.
### Terms
- **Premise**: A statement used to support the conclusion.
- **Validity**: A logical guarantee from premises to conclusion.
- **Soundness**: Validity plus true premises.
- **Unsound**: Failing at least one requirement for soundness.
### Remember
A valid form can carry a false premise, so validity alone does not prove an argument sound.
Related Questions
- Upon successfully finishing the TCPS 2: CORE research ethics tutorial, learners are issued an official _____ of completion to serve as formal verification of their training.(basic)
- Select ALL statements supported by the course material about the Tri-Council Policy Statement, 2nd edition: Core tutorial.(intermediate)
- The course material says that completing the Tri-Council Policy Statement, 2nd edition: Core tutorial may be required for research work connected to a diploma or degree.(basic)
- In technology ethics education, what is the primary objective of having students complete a professional reflection connecting research ethics principles to their future career paths?(intermediate)
- The Tri-Council Policy Statement: Ethical Conduct for Research Involving Humans, 2nd edition: Core tutorial is standardized by which body, according to the course material?(basic)
Want to practice more questions like this?
Join myBenkio free and practice past questions for your Nigerian university courses with AI explanations for every answer.
Start Practicing Free