Mere Christianityintermediate
Explain Lewis’s account of why the Christian view of evil differs from Dualism.
Answer
A strong answer should define Dualism as two independent and equal powers of good and evil, then explain Lewis’s claim that evil depends on good capacities and goods that it misuses. It should include the idea that cruelty, for example, is pursued for pleasure or power, and clarify that Christianity still treats evil as real while denying that it is an independent original principle.
Explanation
### Why this is right
Lewis’s contrast is not between a world with evil and one without it. He accepts that evil is real but argues that it is dependent, corrupted good rather than an equal source of reality.
### The concept
Dualism needs a standard by which one power can be called good and the other evil. Lewis argues that this standard would be more fundamental than either power. He also reasons that evil actions pursue or misuse goods such as pleasure, power, and existence. Christianity can therefore describe a real cosmic conflict while treating evil as rebellion within a creation that ultimately belongs to God.
### What a good answer covers
- A clear definition of Dualism.
- Evil’s dependence on goods or capacities it corrupts.
- The difference between rejecting evil’s reality and rejecting its independence.
### Remember
Lewis’s account makes evil real but derivative, not an equal creator alongside God.
Related Questions
- In Lewis’s piano analogy, what corresponds to the Moral Law?(intermediate)
- Explain how Lewis responds to the objection that moral rules are merely social conventions.(intermediate)
- Reconstruct Lewis’s inference from the Moral Law to a power behind the universe, and identify one limit he places on that inference.(intermediate)
- In Lewis’s account, what makes free will valuable despite making evil possible?(intermediate)
- Lewis argues that the Moral Law is simply a description of what human beings usually do.(intermediate)
Want to practice more questions like this?
Join myBenkio free and practice past questions for your Nigerian university courses with AI explanations for every answer.
Start Practicing Free