Skip to content

Select ALL statements that correctly describe validity and soundness.

Answer

Validity is determined by logical form., A sound argument is valid and has true premises., An invalid argument can never be sound.

Explanation

### Why this is right - **A** is true: validity tests whether the conclusion follows from the premises' structure, assuming the premises are true. - **B** is true: soundness requires both valid form and actually true premises. - **D** is true: an invalid argument fails the validity condition that every sound argument must meet. ### The concept Validity and soundness answer different questions. Validity asks whether a true-premise, false-conclusion case is possible. Soundness asks whether the argument is valid and whether its premises are true in fact. A premise can be false even when the logical form is valid, making the argument unsound. An argument can also have a true conclusion while being invalid, because the conclusion may be true for reasons not established by the premises. ### The other options - **C. A valid argument must have factually true premises.** This confuses validity with soundness. Validity holds even when a premise is false, provided the structure still guarantees the conclusion if the premises were true. ### Terms - **Logical form**: The pattern of how premises support a conclusion, apart from their particular subject matter. - **Validity**: A structure that does not permit true premises and a false conclusion together. - **Soundness**: Validity plus true premises. ### Remember Logical form determines validity; factual accuracy is an additional test for soundness.

Related Questions

Want to practice more questions like this?

Join myBenkio free and practice past questions for your Nigerian university courses with AI explanations for every answer.

Start Practicing Free